Why your abandoned cart emails are landing in spam, and how to fix deliverability is a question that keeps many e‑commerce operators up at night, because every lost email means lost revenue from a shopper who was already interested.
The real cost of a spam folder
When a message never reaches the inbox, the opportunity to recover a cart disappears. Studies of cart abandonment show that on average 70 % of shoppers leave a site before completing a purchase. Even if only 10 % of those abandoners would have converted with a well‑timed reminder, a store that generates R250 000 in monthly sales could be missing out on R25 000 simply because the reminder never arrives.
Beyond the immediate loss, a high spam rate harms sender reputation. Email service providers (ESPs) track bounce and complaint rates; a reputation score below 70 % can cause future campaigns to be throttled or blocked, creating a vicious cycle that affects all transactional messages, not just abandoned cart reminders.
Why abandoned cart emails end up in spam
There are three main categories of reasons: authentication, content, and sending behaviour. Each category can be diagnosed with tools such as Google Postmaster Tools or the deliverability reports in your ESP.
1. Authentication failures
- Missing or mis‑configured SPF record. The SPF (Sender Policy Framework) DNS entry tells receiving servers which IP addresses are allowed to send mail for your domain. If the record does not include the ESP’s sending IP, the message is likely to be rejected or marked as spam.
- DKIM not signed. DomainKeys Identified Mail adds a cryptographic signature to the header. Without a valid DKIM signature, many filters treat the email as unauthenticated.
- DMARC policy too strict. A DMARC policy set to “reject” without proper SPF/DKIM alignment will cause the message to be dropped outright.
2. Content triggers
- Spam‑my‑like subject lines. Phrases such as “You won’t believe this” or excessive punctuation raise red flags.
- Heavy use of images. A message that is 90 % image and 10 % text often fails the “image‑to‑text ratio” test used by spam filters.
- Unbalanced links. Including more than three external links, especially to domains with low reputation, can push the score down.
- Missing plain‑text alternative. Many filters penalise HTML‑only messages.
3. Sending behaviour
- Inconsistent sending volume. A sudden spike from 100 to 10 000 emails in a day looks suspicious.
- High bounce or complaint rates. If more than 0.5 % of recipients mark the message as spam, ESPs will downgrade future mail.
- Shared IP reputation. Using a generic shared IP that other senders have abused can drag down your own deliverability.
For a deeper dive into the technical standards, see the Baymard Institute’s checkout usability research, which includes a section on email follow‑up best practices.
Step‑by‑step method to repair deliverability
The following checklist can be applied in a single week, assuming you have access to your DNS provider and ESP dashboard.
Day 1 – Verify authentication
- Log into your DNS console and locate the TXT record for SPF. Ensure it contains the ESP’s sending domain, e.g.,
v=spf1 include:mailservice.com -all. - Generate a DKIM key from your ESP (usually a 2048‑bit key) and add the provided TXT record to DNS.
- Set a DMARC record with a “none” policy for monitoring:
v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:postmaster@yourdomain.com. After a week, review the reports and consider moving to “quarantine”.
Day 2 – Clean up content
- Write a subject line that is under 50 characters, mentions the cart, and avoids all‑caps. Example: “Your cart is waiting – finish checkout”.
- Use a balanced layout: 60 % text, 40 % images. Include a clear call‑to‑action button that links directly to the abandoned cart page.
- Add a plain‑text version of the email. Most ESPs generate this automatically, but verify that it includes the same link and a short description.
- Limit external links to two: one to your store and one to a help article.
Day 3 – Test sending behaviour
- Send a test batch of 100 emails to internal addresses and to a few external accounts (Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo). Use a tool like Mail‑Tester.com to get a spam score.
- Check the ESP’s reputation dashboard. If you are on a shared IP with a reputation below 80, request a dedicated IP or move to a reputable ESP that offers warm‑up.
- Schedule the abandoned cart series to send at 1 hour, 24 hours, and 72 hours after abandonment. Avoid sending more than three reminders per cart.
Day 4 – Warm‑up and monitor
- If you have moved to a new IP, start by sending 500 emails per day, increasing by 20 % each day until you reach your normal volume.
- Track bounce and complaint rates daily. Aim for less than 0.2 % bounce and under 0.1 % complaint.
- Review DMARC aggregate reports. If you see “fail” for DKIM, double‑check the DNS entry and the selector used by the ESP.
Day 5 – Final validation
- Run a deliverability test with a service such as GlockApps or 250ok to confirm inbox placement across major providers.
- Update your internal documentation with the new SPF/DKIM/DMARC values and the approved email template.
- Schedule a monthly audit of bounce and complaint metrics to catch regressions early.
Once these steps are complete, you should see a noticeable lift in open rates. In a hypothetical example, a store that previously recorded a 12 % open rate for abandoned cart emails saw the rate rise to 38 % after fixing authentication and content issues, translating into a 15 % increase in recovered revenue.
Worked hypothetical example
Consider a store that generates 5 000 abandoned carts per month, with an average order value (AOV) of R800. Before any changes, the email series had a 10 % open rate, a 2 % click‑through rate (CTR), and a 1 % conversion rate, resulting in 5 recovered orders (5 000 × 0.10 × 0.02 × 0.01). That is R4 000 of recovered revenue.
After applying the step‑by‑step method, the open rate climbs to 35 %, the CTR to 5 %, and the conversion rate to 2.5 %. The new recovery calculation is 5 000 × 0.35 × 0.05 × 0.025 = 219 orders, or R175 200 in revenue. The incremental gain is R171 200, a 4 300 % increase, demonstrating how fixing deliverability directly impacts the bottom line.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
- Ignoring DMARC reports. Many operators set a “none” policy and forget to review the reports. Use a tool like dmarcian to parse the XML files and act on failures.
- Relying on a single IP. If that IP gets blacklisted, all mail stops. Keep a fallback IP or use an ESP that offers automatic IP rotation.
- Over‑personalising subject lines with dynamic tokens that sometimes fail. If a token resolves to a blank value, the subject can look broken and trigger spam filters. Always include a fallback text.
- Sending from a generic “no‑reply@yourdomain.com”. Recipients are more likely to mark such messages as spam. Use a real‑person address like “support@yourdomain.com”.
- Neglecting list hygiene. Keep your cart reminder list clean by removing addresses that have bounced repeatedly or have not engaged in the past six months.
Quick checklist for immediate action
- Confirm SPF includes your ESP’s domain.
- Publish DKIM TXT record and verify signature.
- Set DMARC to “none” and monitor reports for one week.
- Rewrite subject lines to be under 50 characters and avoid spammy words.
- Balance email layout: at most 40 % images, include plain‑text version.
- Limit external links to two per email.
- Send a test batch and check spam score with Mail‑Tester.com.
- Warm‑up any new IP before full volume.
- Track bounce and complaint rates weekly.
- Schedule a monthly deliverability audit.
If you suspect hidden issues beyond these steps, run a free scan of your store to see where your checkout flow may be leaking revenue and how email performance fits into the picture.
By treating abandoned cart email deliverability as a technical discipline rather than an afterthought, you protect your sender reputation, improve inbox placement, and turn a small fraction of abandoned carts into a reliable revenue stream.
Audience Connect
A Johannesburg digital marketing team: paid advertising, SEO, websites and brand for South African businesses. These guides come from that work. Want help with yours?
Request a proposal